Ice Class Requirements on Side Shell Structures - A comparison of local strength class requirements regarding plastic design of ice-reinforced side shell structures

Sammanfattning: The demand for shipping in Arctic regions is increasing, and with this comes an increased interest inice-strengthened ships. Today there exist several class rules satisfying additional requirements foroperation in geographical areas with ice-infested waters. Hence, it is crucial for classification societies,designers and ship-owners to understand how formulations of each rule-set impact on structuralmembers to be able to design a ship that suits a certain operational purpose.The aim of this thesis is to perform a comparison study on structural properties and steel grades onmid-bodies with a constant cross section, regarding ice-strengthening requirements relevant in the icereinforcedregion. To provide an overview of fundamental differences of ice class rule-sets, acomparison is conducted through case studies in which three different fictitious ships are used. Therule formulations of Det Norske Veritas (DNV), Finnish-Swedish Ice Class Rules (FSICR), IACSPolar Class and the Russian Maritime Register of Shipping (RS) are compared with an emphasis onthe local structure and material requirements. Since the comparison is focused on rule-sets, nonumerical analysis on the strength is considered.To enable comparisons between class rules, a computer code is developed where the rule-sets areadopted. The computer code uses ship particulars together with rule formulations to calculate theoutcome on the actual local strength of each rule-set. Main parameters, i.e. frame spacing, direction offrames, displacement and yield strength in the rule formulation are varied in order to find theirinfluence on the weight and structural properties. In addition to this, issues in the results are identifiedtogether with recommendations of areas that need to be further looked into with a numerical analysison the actual structure.The comparison shows that the direction of framing plays a major role in the reinforcements neededand the total weight outcome on mid-bodies with a constant cross section. Due to the shape of the iceload, transverse framing has favourable requirements on local design in the perspective of weight. Theresult has been validated with the DNV software Nauticus Hull.It is found that when designing a ship according to notations with higher requirements, “tailormade”beam profiles may result in a better distribution of structural safety margins and a lighter structure.The study also shows that requirements on steel grade depending on structural member and thicknessvary between rule-sets. It is concluded that using steel with higher yield strength can be economicalsince it may result in a lower requirement on the grade and less material in the structure. The studyshows a case with a weight-saving of 9% and a cost-saving of 5% when upgrading the yield strength.To be aware of these behaviours one can benefit from this and design an approved structure that fulfilsthe requirements with reduced weight and cost.