Which pronouns are the most difficult? : An Error Analysis of Swedish Students’ Usage of Pronouns: A corpus-based study

Sammanfattning: This corpus-based study aims to better understand the difficulties for Swedish students regarding English pronouns and based on the result give recommendations for the teaching of English pronouns within a Swedish context. The study investigates Swedish students' usage of pronouns in English writing and the result is compared with Köhlmyr’s (2001) result.  The material is taken from the corpus ULEC (Uppsala Learner English Corpus) and consists of 18 048 words. There are 48 essays written by Swedish students in year six and 39 essays from students in year twelve. The youngest and the oldest students from ULEC are chosen to be able to make comparisons between the years. Error Analysis is the method for finding errors and analyzing them. The errors are first analyzed as addition, misinformation (also called substitution), misordering or blends and then as interlingual or intralingual. They are analyzed to better understand the reasons behind them.  The essays contain a total of 56 errors and most of them are analyzed as misinformation caused by interlingual transfer. The most erroneous pronouns are interpreted as the most problematic, which in year six are the reflexive pronouns and in year 12 genitive dependent pronouns. In both years there also occur errors of object pronouns. A similarity with the previous study by Köhlmyr is that the students have difficulties using existential there and instead use the subject pronoun it. A possible reason behind these errors could be the difference between Swedish and English grammar rules which lead to negative transfer. A recommendation for teaching is to focus more on explaining the genitive and reflexive pronouns.